Episode 180: Crystal McCrory Jones

When a woman is found dead in her home, a shoddy investigation stands in the way of the truth. What really happened to Crystal McCrory Jones?

Episode Media

Episode Sources

Episode Transcript

Welcome back to Bite-Sized Crime. This week I’m bringing you a case that still needs answers, but it’s been hindered by a botched investigation that could be standing in the way of the truth. A special thanks to Crystal’s sister Jana for reaching out and generously sharing the case file with me. This episode discusses sensitive topics, so listener discretion is advised.

Crystal Deniece McCrory was born in Crossett, Arkansas, in 1979 and grew up in northeast Louisiana. The second of four siblings, Crystal was bright and cheerful, and she made friends easily. She had a contagious laugh and was known to be a bit of a prankster. Above all, she loved to make others feel special and wanted to help wherever she could.

In 1997, Crystal graduated from Bastrop High School. That fall, she gave birth to her first son, followed by her second son in 2004. Crystal loved being a mom and worked hard to make sure her boys had a safe and loving home to grow up in. Her sister Jana told KTVE, “[Crystal] was an absolutely phenomenal mother. Her whole world revolved around kids; especially her two boys.”

Over the years, Crystal’s little family moved around the country, going as far north as New York before returning to Louisiana. She worked as a server for many years before eventually getting a job working as an office representative at State Farm Insurance. She got her license and wanted to pursue national certification. Crystal was really proud of her hard work and all she had done to build her career.

Around 2017, Crystal started dating a man named Tony Jones. Tony worked as an HVAC technician and taught martial arts classes in the community. When they married in September of 2018, Crystal became a stepmother to Tony’s two children. Their two youngest – Crystal’s son and Tony’s daughter – lived with them in a cozy little house in the town of Oak Grove, Louisiana.

Together, Crystal and Tony worked hard to build up their business – a martial arts dojo in the heart of Oak Grove. They renovated a commercial space on Main Street and steadily grew their client base. They offered classes for all ages, and they made extra money by hosting birthday parties and community events. Tony and Crystal were happy with their blended family and successful business.

On the morning of February 9, 2023, Crystal woke up feeling out of sorts. She told Tony that she was going to call the doctor and make an appointment for that afternoon. Tony left the house around 8am to go work on a refrigerator unit in the neighboring town of Bastrop. A few hours later, he returned to Oak Grove where he got lunch at a local bakery and then headed to the high school to do some maintenance work. He signed his daughter out of school early that afternoon, and the pair ran some errands together before heading to the dojo to prepare for that evening’s classes.

Around 4pm, Tony started to worry that he hadn’t heard from Crystal all day. She should have been at the dojo by then, and she wasn’t responding to his messages or calls. He remembered that she had made a doctor’s appointment and wondered if she was still there. But when Tony called the East Carroll Medical Clinic, he was surprised to learn that Crystal never checked in for her 2:30 appointment.

Concerned that Crystal may have been too sick to leave the house, Tony reached out to a friend – Sheriff’s Deputy Chuck Harris. Tony had previously worked as a reserve deputy for the West Carroll Parish Sheriff’s Office and still maintained many of his contacts. He told Deputy Harris that he had a dojo full of students and couldn’t leave, and asked him to please go check on Crystal since Harris lived just a few houses down the street.

Tony told Deputy Harris that the front door was unlocked and gave him directions to the bedroom where he and Crystal slept. There, Deputy Harris found Crystal lying in bed, a pillow tucked under her arm and a gun in her hand. Her face was covered in blood. It was clear that she was deceased.

Deputy Harris called in a report and was met at the scene by the sheriff, chief deputy, and chief investigator as well as the Oak Grove Police Chief and the coroner. According to their report, there was no sign of a break-in at the house, and no indications of a struggle. Crystal was dressed in her bathrobe, lying under the covers as if she had recently been asleep. In her right hand was a 9mm handgun that had been discharged but had not chambered the next round, indicating that her hand had not remained steady after firing the first shot. The officers noted that the bullet had gone through the headboard and into the wall. They recovered the bullet but could not find the shell casing and assumed it was somewhere in the bedding or in Crystal’s clothing.

Shortly after officers arrived at the scene, Tony pulled up to the house with his daughter. He had already called Crystal’s family, and her sister Jana was on the way. Soon, family members on both sides were gathered in the front yard, waiting for any information they could get. According to Jana, Crystal’s sister-in-law kept saying how depressed Crystal had been, that her medication was surely the reason she had taken her own life. Jana was surprised by this. Crystal had struggled with depression in the past, but that had been over a decade ago, and she had been so happy in her life with Tony. What had changed?

Crystal’s body was taken to the coroner’s office for autopsy, and the family slowly dispersed. That night, Jana texted several friends in law enforcement, asking for their advice. Even though the case wasn’t in their jurisdiction, she hoped they could help her make sure there was a real investigation into her sister’s death.

Meanwhile, Tony was at the sheriff’s office being interviewed. In a recorded statement, he told the chief deputy that he had last talked to his wife around 10am. After completing his work on the refrigerator unit, he had called Crystal on his way back to Oak Grove. They talked for about 20 minutes, and Tony said she sounded normal, but a little tired. Tony ran some errands and got lunch before heading to the high school for his next job. Everything had been fine until he got to the dojo and realized Crystal wasn’t there. That’s when he had asked Deputy Harris to do a welfare check. When Harris told him Crystal was dead, Tony rushed home.

Tony also told the chief deputy that Crystal had been struggling with depression and that her doctor had recently taken her off her antipsychotic medication, which was why she hadn’t been feeling well that morning. When the deputy asked what firearms were in the house, Tony stated that Crystal carried a 9mm handgun for protection, and they also kept a .45 caliber handgun in the nightstand. He said he had lost the key to their gun safe, so both of the guns were easily accessible.

In the days after Crystal’s death, her family met to make funeral arrangements. According to Jana, Tony wanted to have an open casket viewing for Crystal before her cremation. Jana and her sister-in-law took on the difficult task of preparing Crystal’s body, but as they did, they noticed strange injuries on Crystal – multiple bruises on her arms and legs, as well as cuts and abrasions on her left arm. She had clearly just gotten a fresh manicure, but one of her acrylic nails was missing and there was dirt under her fingernails. When the women brought it to the attention of the funeral director, he stated that none of those things would have been caused by Crystal’s autopsy. This was the first sign to Jana that there may be more to Crystal’s case than the family originally believed.

On February 16th, one week after Crystal’s death, Tony contacted the sheriff’s office to let them know that he had found the missing shell casing. It had been sitting on Crystal’s vanity, concealed from view by some of her styling tools. When Crystal’s siblings learned of the discovery, they were alarmed. How had an entire team of deputies and crime scene investigators, and the cleanup crew, missed something so important? What else had been missed? Jana immediately started calling attorneys in Louisiana, asking for help – they had to delay Crystal’s cremation until a proper investigation could be done. Unfortunately, none of her efforts worked, and Crystal’s remains were cremated on February 20th.

A week later, the family received the results of Crystal’s autopsy, and to their surprise, it was riddled with inaccuracies. Crystal’s name was spelled incorrectly on every page. Her hair and eye color was wrong, and the report stated that she had no signs of previous bone fractures, even though Crystal had suffered a major car accident in 2011 that left her with a broken back, multiple broken ribs, and a broken sternum. It listed several diseases that Crystal didn’t have, including diabetes and a history of seizures. Perhaps most shocking of all was that the pathologist listed all of Crystal’s female organs and described them as “unremarkable” in spite of the fact that Crystal had had multiple surgeries in the past, including a hysterectomy, to remove most of those organs.

By this point, Crystal’s siblings were convinced that the investigation into her death had been completely botched – they just weren’t sure if it was due to incompetence, negligence, or flat-out corruption. They decided to do their own investigation. Tony had given Jana Crystal’s laptop, which was synced to her phone, and when Jana opened it, she discovered some alarming patterns.

A week before Crystal’s death, she had logged into Tony’s Google account and turned on his location history, then deleted the email confirming the change. That same day, either Crystal or Tony had logged into their Ring account and accessed their doorbell camera footage, even though the sheriff had told the family that the camera hadn’t been active in over a month.

Also, the night before Crystal died, Tony had deleted several contacts from his phone, including a chief deputy, a coroner, a pastor, and the manager of the Bakery Barn, the restaurant he visited on February 9th.

In looking at Tony’s location data, Jana discovered some odd movements on the day Crystal died. After leaving the maintenance job in Bastrop at 10am, Tony drove back to Oak Grove and arrived at the West Carroll Sheriff’s Department at 10:53am, where he stayed for 15 minutes. He hadn’t mentioned this in his recorded statement. After signing his daughter out of school that afternoon, Tony slowly drove around Oak Grove for 35 minutes before stopping at the Sonic Drive-In. He then stopped at Walmart before presumably heading to the dojo, where he called the doctor’s office, learned that Crystal hadn’t shown up for her appointment, and called Deputy Harris to do a welfare check.

According to the location data, after Tony learned of Crystal’s death, it took him 14 minutes to drive from the dojo to their house, the exact time it would take if he was driving the speed limit, not rushing as he had indicated to Crystal’s family. Then, when the chief deputy had asked Tony to come to the sheriff’s office to make his statement, it took him 42 minutes to drive 12 miles – a trip that should have taken just 15 minutes.

All of these odd details didn’t sit well with Crystal’s siblings, but when they brought everything to the sheriff’s attention, they were assured that none of it was important – it didn’t change the facts of the case. Jana even told the sheriff about a package that was delivered the day of Crystal’s death. Her cousin was the delivery driver, and she had told Jana that at 1:16pm on February 9th, she had arrived at Tony and Crystal’s house with a FedEx package addressed to Tony – it was a cell phone he had ordered. She noticed that Crystal’s Tahoe and Tony’s work truck were both parked in the driveway, but no one answered the door when she rang the doorbell. She often stopped to chat with Crystal when making deliveries, since they had grown up together, so she thought it was odd that no one came to the door. Again, the sheriff didn’t seem to think this was important information, and neither did the district attorney.

But there were other things on Crystal’s laptop that concerned her siblings. As far back as December, there were signs that Crystal suspected that Tony was having an affair. She had clearly been tracking his location, and had kept screenshots showing him at a hotel in Bastrop on December 27th. Tony hadn’t done much to dispel those suspicions. He had brought a female friend with him to view Crystal’s body at the funeral home, and just four days after her death, he had searched, “What is the appropriate time to date after the death of a spouse?” On February 15th, he booked a rental car in Hawaii for March. Not long after that, he changed his Facebook status to single. Jana also found evidence on the laptop that Tony had accounts on multiple dating websites.

Frustrated with the sheriff’s dismissal of their concerns, Crystal’s siblings decided to file a FOIA request, asking for all the documents related to Crystal’s case. When the documents finally arrived, there was even more evidence of a deficient, negligent investigation.

First of all, when law enforcement arrived at the scene, no one canvassed the area or spoke with Crystal and Tony’s neighbors. There were at least five trained officers at the scene, and none of them thought to take any witness statements? Although Tony and Crystal lived in a rural area, they had multiple neighbors who could have seen or heard something around the time Crystal died.

Then, there was Tony’s interview with the chief deputy on the night of February 9th. The interview started with the deputy stating, “I’ll be taking this statement from Tony in reference to a self-inflicted gunshot wound of his wife,” clearly indicating that investigators had already made up their mind about Crystal’s cause of death. The deputy asked very few follow-up questions and ended the interview just 7 minutes after it began. Tony was never brought in for more questioning.

In the entire case file handed over to the family, there were less than 40 pictures of the crime scene. In several shots, the family dog is lying on the bed next to Crystal’s body, a clear indication that the scene was not properly secured. There were also two photos of the bullet taken with a phone and labeled as screenshots that were dated several days after Crystal’s death. There was no visible blood on the bullet in either picture. There were also photos of the supposedly missing shell casing in plain view, not hidden as Tony had claimed.

In the coroner’s report, Crystal’s time of death was scratched out and changed without explanation, and the toxicology report was different from the one the family had seen during a meeting with the district attorney.

In the ballistics report, the gun was incorrectly identified as a Ruger EC9, when it was actually an LC9. Neither Crystal’s nor Tony’s hands were tested for gunshot residue on the day of her death, and the ballistics evidence wasn’t sent for testing until March 27th, nearly two months later.

There are so many discrepancies and mistakes in the case file that it would take hours to list them all. Some of them are big and egregious, while others are small and seemingly insignificant, such as the time Crystal’s body was taken from the home being listed as 6:00pm when it actually happened 20 minutes before that. Big or small, all of the inconsistencies add up to a mess of an investigation.

In the three years since Crystal’s death, her siblings have taken up the case on their own, hiring a private investigator and continuing to seek out information that might bring them to the truth. They have major doubts that Crystal would take her own life, especially without leaving a note for her children and loved ones. There were so many wonderful things happening in her life around that time. She had spent a lovely Christmas with her youngest son on leave from the Navy. Her oldest son and his wife had a baby on the way, making Crystal a grandmother for the first time. And she had recently passed the national certification exam for her insurance license, something she was incredibly proud of. Crystal had always been open about her struggles with depression and had actively sought out professional help. On the morning of her death, she had made an appointment to see her doctor to sort out her medication. If she had indeed died by suicide, what had brought her to that point?

Crystal’s siblings suspect that there was more happening behind closed doors than anyone knew. Tony and Crystal were struggling financially and had quite a bit of credit card debt. Jana also unearthed allegations against Tony in regards to inappropriate relations with a minor for which he was investigated by Child Protective Services years earlier. According to Jana, rumors were swirling around Oak Grove about Tony’s behavior with young girls at the dojo, and parents had started pulling their kids out. Had Crystal found out about the allegations after the sudden drop in enrollment? Did it have anything to do with her death?

The family also wonders if Tony’s connections to the West Carroll Sheriff’s Office contributed to the shoddy investigation. They allege that although Tony no longer worked for the sheriff’s office, he continued to portray himself as an on-call deputy and listed the sheriff’s office as his place of work on Facebook. He maintained close relationships with several other deputies, and he still kept his bulletproof vest in the house. When Tony found the missing shell casing, he asked Crystal’s brother to not make a big deal of it, to not question the chief deputy as a favor to him. Typically, when cases involve even a hint of conflict of interest, the state police are brought in to investigate, but that was not done in Crystal’s case, something the family believes was a major misstep.

In February of 2026, on the three year anniversary of Crystal’s death, her family gathered together to celebrate her life. Jana told KNOE that they just want the truth, no matter what it is. “[We want] to know what really happened to her because certain procedures weren’t followed. So now we’re just advocating for those policies and procedures to be followed through [in] all cases.”

Jana also said that they have asked the state police to take a look at the case and are requesting that Crystal’s cause of death be changed from suicide to undetermined. “Let’s let a fresh set of eyes come in… Show me some evidence that shows that somebody else did it or that she possibly did it. I’m past being angry, I just want justice.”

Crystal McCrory Jones was a wonderful sister, mother, wife, and friend, a woman who loved with her whole heart. She deserves a proper investigation, and her family deserves the truth. Jana has started a petition to get Crystal’s case reopened by the Louisiana State Police. There’s a link in the show notes if you’d like to add your name.

If you or someone you know is struggling with depression or suicidal thoughts, please reach out for help. Call or text 988 or visit 988lifeline.org to chat with a trained counselor who can connect you to the support and resources you need.